Judges Critique

 

2nd Place

2004 DSA Winter Lyric Contest

 

EDGE OF THE WORLD
By Claude Diamond

 

Judge 1

I like this a lot, good use of imagery, proper title selection and placement.
My only nit is the bridge really feels more like verse 3.
It doesn't allow the melody writer to contrast.

 

Judge 2

We've all heard about the homeless and this song makes him human.  I though the hook was excellent and worked well in the song. The rhyme scheme was also good.

 

Judge 3

Good title and hook. Good story. I especially liked the 1st verse with the contrasting the height from which this person fell, from the ivory towers to the park bench.  3rd line of the chorus seemed too much of a tongue twister.